GoHotelly
4-star hotel Check-in 15:00 · Check-out 11:00

Jedediah Hawkins Inn

Elegant 4.7-star 1863 boutique hotel with upscale New American dining, rustic speakeasy & LGBTQ+ friendly atmosphere in Jamesport, NY. 444 guest reviews.

400 S Jamesport Ave, Jamesport, NY 11947, United States View on map
9.4/10
Exceptional Based on 447 recent guest reviews
Free Wi-Fi Free breakfast Free parking Accessible Air-conditioned
What recent guests emphasize

Exceptional hospitality and a memorable dining experience

Guests highlight the attentive, professional staff and the beautifully maintained historic setting. The on-site restaurant and speakeasy offer standout food and drinks, making the inn a popular choice for special occasions and leisurely stays on Long Island's East End.

Guests often praise

  • Outstanding, attentive service from knowledgeable and caring staff, notably event coordinators and attendants.
  • Beautiful, cozy rooms with charming historic details and well-maintained grounds.
  • Highly acclaimed food and drinks, including breakfast, dinner selections, and creative cocktails in the speakeasy.
  • An intimate, picturesque venue favored for weddings, celebrations, and special events.
  • The warm, friendly atmosphere that adds to the overall guest experience.

Worth knowing

  • The inn can be busy during dining hours, indicating its popularity; reservations are recommended.
  • Some guests discover favorite rooms like the Rose room and the top floor Widows Peak, which may require advance booking.
  • While the inn shines for events and meals, some visitors mention not always dining on-site for every meal.
  • Location suits guests interested in exploring nearby beaches, wineries, and local attractions on a largely rural peninsula.

Best for

  • Couples seeking a romantic or celebratory getaway with upscale dining and charming ambiance.
  • Guests attending or hosting weddings and special events looking for dedicated, seamless service.
  • Visitors wanting to experience a boutique historic inn with a strong commitment to hospitality.
  • Travelers interested in exploring Long Island's wine country, local farmstands, and nearby attractions.
  • LGBTQ+ friendly travelers seeking an inclusive and welcoming environment.
Compare booking partners

Open this hotel on the platform you trust.

GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.

Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

About this property

Welcome to Jedediah Hawkins Inn

Dating back to 1863, this boutique hotel combines historic charm with elegant accommodations. Guests can enjoy well-appointed rooms and suites that reflect a blend of traditional style and comfort. The property features a notable New American restaurant praised for its quality cuisine, alongside a rustic speakeasy bar that adds a unique social space for visitors.

Located at 400 S Jamesport Ave in Jamesport, NY, this inn is positioned within a largely rural peninsula known for its vineyards, farmstands, locavore dining, and proximity to attractions like the Long Island Aquarium. This setting appeals especially to travelers seeking a quieter atmosphere with access to local food and wine experiences.

The inn serves as a popular wedding and event venue, with numerous guest reviews highlighting the attentive staff and seamless event coordination. Many past visitors have complimented the beautiful grounds and memorable dining experiences, making it a favored choice for weddings, anniversaries, and special celebrations.

Welcoming a diverse crowd, including LGBTQ+ travelers, the property maintains a rating of 4.7 based on over 440 reviews, reflecting consistent guest satisfaction. Check-in is available from 3 PM with checkout by 11 AM, offering a convenient schedule for stays.

Nearby hotels such as Aqua Beach Hotel and Jamesport Bay Suites offer alternative accommodations within a few miles, but the Jedediah Hawkins Inn stands out for those prioritizing historic character, locally inspired cuisine, and a peaceful East End environment.

Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.
Facilities & essentials

What's on-site and what you should know before you arrive

The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.

Most popular facilities

Free Wi-Fi
Free breakfast
Free parking
Accessible
Air-conditioned
Kid-friendly
Restaurant
Golf course
Bar
Smoke-free

Not available at this property

Pool
Pet-friendly
Airport shuttle
Fitness center
Verified guest reviews

What recent guests are actually saying

Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.

MB
Mark Berenshteyn Mar 28, 2026
10

Thank you Ilias and the entire team for helping make our wedding an unforgettable and magical experience. Everything was perfect, our attendant Erin did an amazing job making sure we weren't stressing about anything and could just enjoy our wedding (which we did not expect to). Your team is highly skilled and seamlessly takes care of every detail. Our guests loved the venue and all of the food and drinks (whoever pulled all of the espresso is an unsung hero, the guests loved the espresso martinis). Even my picky Grandma was blown away. We will definitely be coming back for anniversaries. Thank you for giving us a perfect day we will always remember!

AL
al leclaire Mar 19, 2026
10

I found this place at the last minute and I am so happy to have found it. Stayed in the Rose room and it was so beautiful and cozy. We did not eat dinner there but the place was packed and everyone raved about the food. We did have breakfast and it was absolutely amazing. I would go just for breakfast. The service was 2nd to none. They let us go into the top floor room that houses the widows peak. It was stunning you could fit 20 people sleeping in that room. It is so worth staying there when visiting. Stay and have breakfast. Make sure to go into the speakeasy have a drink and get beat playing connect four.

CS
Collins Sigler Mar 09, 2026
10

We chose the Mattituck area for our "minimoon" celebration, and visiting Jedediah Hawkins Inn was easily the highlight of our trip. From the moment we arrived, we were treated with amazing care; the hospitality here is truly top-tier. We started the evening in the Speakeasy, which has such a cool vibe—definitely don't skip a drink there! When it came time for dinner, the staff was incredibly accommodating and able to seat us a bit earlier than our reservation, which we really appreciated. The food was spectacular. I cannot recommend the burger enough, and the pork chop was honestly one of the best I have ever had. Everything was cooked to perfection. A huge thank you to our incredible server who went above and beyond to make our celebration feel one-of-a-kind. We can't wait to come back!

LF
Lyndsey Fernandez Mar 05, 2026
10

My husband and I got married here in 2021, and came back in Jan of 2026 for our baby shower. The best place on the east end! The food is amazing, and the service is unbeatable. Jedediah holds such a special place in our hearts, and truly a place that is just incredibly magical.

PE
Patrick Engel Feb 27, 2026
10

We couldn’t have picked a better place for our reception than Jedediah Hawkins Inn. The grounds and venue are stunning, full of character, and gave our guests such a memorable experience. The food was outstanding—beautifully prepared and absolutely delicious, with so many of our guests commenting on how much they enjoyed it. A huge thank you to Ilias, our event coordinator, whose professionalism and attention to detail made everything run seamlessly. And to Erin, our bridal attendant, who was wonderful—always one step ahead and made sure we were comfortable and cared for throughout the day. Jedediah Hawkins Inn is a truly special place, and the staff went above and beyond to make our wedding unforgettable.

EG
Ellen Greenfield Feb 24, 2026
10

We celebrated my son's wedding at the Jedidiah Hawkins Inn in November. The experience exceeded our expectations in every way. The amazing and highly experienced staff were warm and friendly, catered to our every need and ensured that the entire event ran smoothly. The rooms were lovely, the grounds were beautiful and a perfect setting for photos, even in November. The food was outstanding both the reception dinner and brunch the next day. Multiple guests commented that it was the best food they ever had at a wedding. The whole experience felt warm and intimate and went off without a hitch. I highly recommend.

MD
Michelle Dionisio Jan 31, 2026
10

Fabulous get away ! The grounds were gorgeous with fresh flowers and old world charm everywhere. The home is perfected detail and charm in every room. The service top notch and the food wow!! Restaurant and breakfast was delicious!!! Priced so reasonable as well . Location also great. Beaches and wineries everywhere. We will definitely be back!!

TZ
Tim Zhang Jan 09, 2026
10

It's hard to overstate how wonderful the staff and facilities are at Jedediah Hawkins Inn are. It was the perfect setting for our fall wedding and we got rave reviews from our guests about the delicious food and drinks (not to mention how beautiful the venue is). The inn rooms were delightful and the speakeasy was a fun way to end the night! Special thanks to Ilias for all his help during the planning process, Erin for how helpful and attentive she was during the day of proceedings, and Eugenia for all her help during the farewell breakfast on the morning after. We highly recommend you visit or stay here if you have the opportunity.

Location & neighborhood

Where you'll find Jedediah Hawkins Inn

Jamesport, New York, USA

Largely rural peninsula known for vineyards, farmstands, locavore dining & the Long Island Aquarium.

People also viewed

Similar Hotels in New York

Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.

5510 FL-7, Hollywood, FL 33314, United States

Dolce by Wyndham Hollywood

Stay at Dolce by Wyndham Hollywood, a 3.8star LGBTQ+ friendly hotel with a swimming pool near top attractions and airports in Hol...

3.8 (380) View
22601 E Cloud Rd, Queen Creek, AZ 85142, United States

The Cozy Peach at Schnepf Farms

Experience comfort at The Cozy Peach at Schnepf Farms, a 4.6rated wellness hotel and B&B in Queen Creek, AZ, featuring LGBTQ+ fri...

4.6 (21) View
100 Tammy Ln, Beebe, AR 72012, United States

Rodeway Inn Beebe

Stay at Rodeway Inn Beebe with free parking, indoor/outdoor pools, and petfriendly rooms. Close to Cockrill’s Country Critters an...

4.5 (272) View
1530 E Dixon Blvd, Shelby, NC 28152, United States

Oak Tree Lodge

Stay at Oak Tree Lodge, a 3.8star motel in Shelby, NC. Kidfriendly amenities and close to Crowders Mountain State Park, Kings Mo...

3.8 (45) View
4835 CA-158, June Lake, CA 93529, United States

Yosemite Gateway Chalet

Stay at Yosemite Gateway Chalet in June Lake, CA. Enjoy free WiFi, parking, hot tub, and close access to June Mountain & Mammoth ...

4.8 (41) View
606 SW Coast Hwy #101, Newport, OR 97365, United States

Econo Lodge Newport

Econo Lodge Newport offers free WiFi, continental breakfast, and parking. Rated 3.4/5 with 508 reviews, located near Yaquina Bay S...

3.4 (508) View
1525 TX-46, Seguin, TX 78155, United States

Super 8 by Wyndham Seguin

Enjoy free WiFi, breakfast, and parking at Super 8 by Wyndham Seguin, a casual hotel off I10 near ZDT's Amusement Park and Natur...

3.6 (237) View
888 N Pacific Coast Hwy, El Segundo, CA 90245, United States

Hampton Inn & Suites LAX El Segundo

Stay at Hampton Inn & Suites LAX El Segundo with free WiFi, indoor pool, gym, and bar. Located 2 miles from LAX and close to Sant...

4.4 (1,742) View
4 Grove Isle Dr, Coconut Grove, FL 33133, United States

Grove Hotel Partners LLC

Stay at Grove Hotel Partners LLC in Coconut Grove, FL. Enjoy free WiFi, parking, pool, and easy access to Vizcaya Museum & Garden...

4.1 (49) View
Share your stay

Stayed at Jedediah Hawkins Inn? Help the next traveler decide.

Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.

Your email is only used to verify the review — it won't be shown publicly.